NOVEMBER 23, 2009
   Login or create a new account  ?
Join Washington Blade on FacebookJoin Washingtonblade on MyspaceJoin Washington Blade on Twitter!
Roger Lancaster, an anthropology professor at George Mason University, said the modern idea of marriage is only 200 years ago and was developed at the time of the Industrial Revolution. (Photo by Leigh H. Mosley)
 
 
MORE INFO
MORE INFO
American Anthropological Association
2200 Wilson Blvd, Suite 600
Arlington, VA 22201
703-528-1902
www.aaanet.org
MOST VIEWED
 
Anthropologists debunk ‘traditional marriage’ claim
Group claims Bush’s arguments don’t reflect history

HOME > NEWS > NATIONAL NEWS

Apr 16, 2004  |  By: ADRIAN BRUNE  | COMMENTS      Printer Friendly Version



continued...

equivalent to marriage vows, and to me, these single-sex orders provide the larger evidence of the sanctioning of same-sex unions,” Palacios said. “They also procured children in the sense of establishing schools, orphanages and hospitals, which mirrored or paralleled the intent of marriage.”

The American Anthropological Association created its statement denouncing Bush at the suggestion of Dan Segal, another anthropologist who points to the application of marriage to same-sex couples in both a classical and modern context.

Centuries after the Greeks and early Christians sanctified same-sex unions, Native Americans still practice a widespread same-sex tradition known as the berdache, in which two spirit males — men who are not tied to one gender — marry, provided they undergo a social and spiritual transformation, Lancaster said. One spouse might identify as female, but both remain biologically male.

Many modern societies don’t even draw a distinction between homosexual and heterosexual in their pairings, Lancaster said, choosing a more free association regarding sexual or kinship ties. The Nuer of Sudan, as well as other African societies, institutionalized female same-sex marriages to preserve the lineage of one woman’s family. These same-sex unions also exist in the form of cohabitation after an occasional “ghost marriage” of a woman to a dead man.


Polygamy came first

Though some conservative politicians decry same-sex marriages as opening the door to polygamy, polygamy is actually the time-tested method of sexual bonding, anthropologists said. Outlawed in the United States in 1879, it still survives among some Mormons and is practiced consistently in the Muslim world.

Bush’s model of marriage — the heterosexual nuclear family — actually evolved during the Industrial Revolution, as transient populations, mass education, the women’s rights movement and the creation of leisure time tested marriage’s tradition, according to Lancaster.

Women also moved up in status from property to partner, and children from a source of labor to the treasured outcomes of a loving bond. Early 20th century magazines, such as the Ladies’ Home Journal, seized upon this idea and circulated it through mainstream America, scholars noted.

Though all don’t necessarily support same-sex marriage, most anthropologists and social scientists agreed that the American Anthropologic

Previous Page 1 Page 2


email       password


Please review and follow Washington Blade’s current Comment and Discussion Policy. Guidelines updated as of August 22nd, 2009. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

Spacer
Spacer
Spacer

Washington Blade Window Media CONTACT US: E-mail | Masthead | Location and Directions
© 2009 | A Window Media LLC Publication | Privacy Policy
Advertise with us!